The Heart Behind Religious Activity (Mark 2:18-22)
Talking Points:
- In Mark 2:18-22 Jesus challenges the religious police of his day. Faith always expresses itself in certain activities (like fasting), but toxic religion uses this as a litmus test to police the spiritual life of others. Mark 2:18
- Jesus uses a wedding feast to illustrate that fasting doesn’t make sense at a party. Religion treats spiritual practices like requirements on a checklist, but Jesus treats them as opportunities to express your heart toward God. Mark 2:19-20
- Jesus expands the principle with the example of putting new wine into old wineskins. Religion takes a rigid, legalistic approach to spiritual practices as an end in themselves, while in Christ these practices express the dynamic relationship we have with God by grace. Mark 2:21-22
Discussion:
- What’s your background regarding faith and religion?
- Make a list of spiritual practices that people are the “Religion Police” about.
- Read Mark 2:18-20. What do you believe about fasting? Is Jesus against it?
- What does it mean that Jesus is the groom and we are the bride?
- Read Mark 2:21-22. Explain the two illustrations that Jesus gave. What is their spiritual significance?
- Read Revelation 19:6-9. How does someone get invited to the Marriage Supper of the Lamb?
See Also:
Shownotes:
Opening / Hook
Big Idea: Religious systems want to authorize what religious practices (like fasting) are required, and how they are to be performed, believing that these practices prove who is worthy before God. This form of religion values doing the activities for their own sake. But Jesus reveals that since the Messiah has come, we can’t do religious activity the old way anymore. Thus he is more concerned about heart attitude and purpose than mere conformity. Jesus still endorses religious practices (like fasting). But he shows that religious practices are not about measuring up, but express a growing relationship with God from our inner heart.
The flow of the text:
- Jesus criticized. Mark 2:18
- His first response: there’s a time to fast and not fast. Mark 2:19-20
- His second response: the approach of the Pharisees is not compatible with what the Messiah brings. Mark 2:21-22
The Religion Police
- Mark 2:18 Once when John’s disciples and the Pharisees were fasting, some people came to Jesus and asked, “Why don’t your disciples fast like John’s disciples and the Pharisees do?”
- This question feels like a critique, not an honest inquiry
- It’s an accusation = Why don’t you do what you’re supposed to?
- Important note: this critique is not leveled against spiritual outsiders / heathens / unbelievers
- Last week: saw attitude of religion toward irreligious people
- Today: attitude of religion toward people who supposedly should know better → less zealous / righteous / serious followers of God
- Explore fasting in the OT
- The law of Moses does not command or regulate fasting for God’s covenant people
- But it was widely practiced as a custom
- By individuals and corporately as a nation
- Note: Torah commands humbling oneself on Day of Atonement
- This was clearly understood in later Judaism to include fasting
- Although the Hebrews words for “fasting” are not present
- Fasting reflects the recognition that something is wrong (in nation, my life, etc)
- Coupled with a hope / longing for deliverance
- So fasting becomes a sign of grief / mourning
- Fasting reflects a drawing to the presence of God
- Humbling oneself in the process
- So fasting becomes a sign of repentance and seeking forgiveness
- Compare fasting in 1st century Judaism
- Don’t want to stereotype Jewish fasting as completely negative or hypocritical
- But it could definitely trend that way
- Over time fasting became more ritualized / more codified
- In some circles → violation of fasting rules seen as actual sin
- Elevated to an elitist function = to mark off who is spiritually elite / better
- See Pharisee in Luke 18:12 condemned by Jesus for his elitist attitude toward fasting
- If Jesus’ followers weren’t fasting → called into question their piety, sincerity and devotion to God
- Contemporary issue → when religious people believe certain kinds of religious activity are necessary
- In this case, the discussion is about fasting → but not limited to that one practice alone
- Empty religion and true faith have this in common = spiritual practices involved
- Prayer / giving to the poor / fasting / attending worship / etc.
- But the religious mindset looks at certain practices as a test of one’s piety / rel’ship with God
- These practices define the code you’re expected to live up to
- Try hard to live up to the code themselves
- That becomes a way to show your spiritual superiority
- When they can’t / don’t → hide it & still preach it
- Why religious-minded people often come off as hypocrites
- But also: watching others → accuse them of not living up to the code
- Contemptuous of people who don’t conform / don’t perform
- Why aren’t YOU doing it?
- The more religious, the more they feel like it’s their calling to police other people’s relationship with God
- Use outward expression of faith / religion to do so
- Give some examples
- Why don’t you dress up for church?
- Why aren’t your services more “reverent”?
- Heard this week: Why don’t you do deep theological Bible studies?
- How about daily quiet time? Never commanded in Bible
- It’s a great idea to set aside time for daily communion with God
- But it’s exactly the kind of activity people use to judge others & measure ‘self against others
Trans: Jesus has two responses to the critique → the first is in vv. 19-20
Wedding Guests
- Mark 2:19-20 Jesus replied, “Do wedding guests fast while celebrating with the groom? Of course not. They can’t fast while the groom is with them. But someday the groom will be taken away from them, and then they will fast.
- Jesus draws from common experience → a wedding celebration
- In this illustration: the groom represents Jesus
- The wedding guests represent his followers
- Nobody fasts at a wedding! Fasting is not how you celebrate.
- But after the wedding → the guests are separated from their friend
- So they might mourn that separation
- The Messiah has come / his presence changes things
- Perhaps Jesus is foreshadowing his death here
- Which was an occasion for fasting / mourning
- Perhaps just acknowledging that he won’t be present like this forever
- Implication: a time is coming when Jesus’ followers would fast
- Like John and his disciples / like the Pharisees
- As Xians, we do fast
- To remind us of our dependence on God / need for his mercy
- Apply this to spiritual practices / activities
- Jesus draws our attention to the WHY
- Asking his critics to consider the true meaning of fasting
- Fasting, then, is not about checking off a box
- Doing a religious practice just because you’re supposed to
- In this illustration → fasting is a reflection of a person’s genuine heart
- When you’re celebrating God’s goodness / mercy / salvation
- That’s not a time to fast
- Bc fasting is not the right activity to express that inner response of praise & gratitude
- When you’re mourning → that’s the time to fast
- Mourning loss / but also mourning sin
- Bc fasting is the right activity to express sorrow / need / brokenness
- The same principle applies to every spiritual practice / discipline / activity
- Shouldn’t be done to look righteous
- To keep score
- To feel better than other people
- Shouldn’t be a way we measure others or ourselves before God
- Bc those kind of things are easy to fake
- Easy to separate from the motives / attitudes within
- SHOULD be done to express a genuine heart response to God
- Examples: why attend worship?
- Why read Bible every day?
- Etc. → other examples
New Clothes and Wineskins
- Jesus has two responses to the critique → the second is in vv. 21-22
- The first response was clearly addressing the idea of fasting
- This one is a little more obscure
- Harder to see the connection → but he is still answering the original question
- I think Jesus is expanding the question beyond fasting
- I think he is saying, “Speaking of the Pharisees and their practices…”
- Mark 2:21-22 Besides, who would patch old clothing with new cloth? For the new patch would shrink and rip away from the old cloth, leaving an even bigger tear than before. And no one puts new wine into old wineskins. For the wine would burst the wineskins, and the win and the skins would both be lost. New wine calls for new wineskins.
- Jesus gives two similar illustrations to make his point
- 1st: you don’t patch old clothing with new cloth
- 2nd: you don’t put new wine into old wineskins
- Similar idea in both
- 1st illustration: talking about making a repair to a worn garment
- It has a tear that needs to be patched
- Don’t use brand new cloth to repair the tear
- Old cloth of the clothing has already shrunk
- New cloth will shrink when it is washed the first time
- So it will pull away → the tear will be worst
- 2nd illustration: talking about storing wine that is not yet fermented
- Wineskins are made of leather = skin of goat or lamb
- Old leather doesn’t have much “give” / elasticity anymore → won’t stretch
- New wine is unfermented grape juice
- But as it ferments into wine, it creates gasses as byproduct
- So the wine expands → leather has to stretch
- In old, rigid leather, the expanding wine will burst the wineskin
- The wineskin is ruined
- The wine is spilt and lost
- But what do these illustrations have to do with fasting?
- The central idea is common → incompatibility with old and new
- But: old and new what?
- Old and new spiritual practices / activities?
- Is he saying that new practices have to replace the old ones?
- That’s why his disciples don’t fast?
- Bc fasting is now obsolete?
- That doesn’t seem to be the case
- 1st: Jesus says (20): the friends of the bridegroom will fast at some point
- 2nd: other places, Jesus endorsed fasting
- Matthew 6: “when you fast…” / not IF you fast or DON’T fast
- So what is the old / new incompatibility Jesus is getting at?
- What’s clear: something NEW has arrived
- Most obvious NEW thing on the scene is the Messiah himself
- With Jesus’ coming a new day is dawning
- That raises the question: what is the OLD thing Jesus has in mind?
- How is that thing related to the Pharisees?
- The Pharisees were devoted to God, yes
- But in practice → their true devotion was to fulfilling the rules
- They were committed to the ceremonial law of Moses
- Equally committed to their own traditions of interpreting the law of Moses
- So their approach to religious activity was inflexible / brittle
- What Jesus called “traditions of men”
- Rules added to God’s law
- But also: trying to fulfill God’s law outwardly w/o change of heart
- That seems to be the old wineskins here =
- The legalistic system of traditions erected by man-made religion
- We could say: their approach was based on LAW
- Jesus invites his followers to a vibrant, dynamic rel’ship with God
- One based, not on LAW, but on GRACE
- Yes, religious activities are certainly part of that
- But it’s not about keeping the rules
- A rel’ship with God that’s by grace alone (new wine)
- Can’t be compatible with an approach that’s governed by merely keeping the law (old wineskin)
- Fasting, etc are about cultivating a rel’ship with God from the heart
- Not just skin deep
- Not just practicing these things as an end in themself
- Not just about fulfilling some outward formality
CONCLUSION
- Application: why do you do the things you do as a Christian?
- Why do you pray? Read your Bible? Come to church?
- What do those things mean to you?
- External ceremony and tradition?
- Or a transformed heart?
- YES to fasting; YES to other spiritual practices
- They’re valuable to us
- Not as an end in themselves
- Not as a way to measure who’s elite or not
- Not to pump up myself and criticism others
- Not with such rigidity that there is no freedom to express one’s true heart toward God
- But as expressions of our love for God / our desire for him / conviction of our sin against him / etc
Transcript
Speaker 1 00:00:35 Well, yeah. You know, um, what's interesting to me is that, that every religious system on the globe, whether it's Hindu or Buddhist, or Muslim, or, or traditional Christian or Mormon or whatever it might be, has a list of prescribed religious practices or activities. And a lot of 'em look the same cuz almost every group prays that Muslims pray, Christians pray. Um, and, and so down the list. So what, what differentiates us, and it's a great question for us to ask ourselves. Like, like why do we pray? Um, why do we do the things we do? Like what going to church or reading our Bible or whatever the list is, the sort of approved list for, you know, Christians in our culture today. Um, you know, what does it mean to us and and what are our motives? What's going on with those things? And those are, that's a question that gets raised, uh, with Jesus in, um, here in Mark chapter two. And it's get, it's raised by people who are really asking him why he doesn't do a religious activity that they want to do.
:Speaker 0 00:02:32 And, and some people believe that the list is clear in the Bible Yeah. Um, about how we're supposed to worship God. And there are certainly a lot of things in there, a lot of disciplines, a lot of commands and calls to be obedient and things that God has said to do in the old and both the New Testament. But yet, if we look at it a little bit deeper, we need to understand that not all of those things, um, mean what they mean at first glance. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:04:19 Yeah. So, in Mark chapter two, verse 18, we're gonna get right to this interaction. It says, once when John's disciples and the Pharisees were fasting, some people came to Jesus and asked, why don't your disciples fast like John's disciples and the Pharisees do. So these Pharisees see, uh, uh, Jesus and his disciples, and they're questioning, how come your guys are different from our guys? Right. How come you, if, if you say that you've, you're you're of the same faith you've come to, you know, save and, and be the Messiah, then how come you're not acting the way that we feel like you should be acting?
:Speaker 1 00:05:48 Now it became an important practice, and it has important reasons for doing it, but I couldn't find a place that actually commands that makes it a non-negotiable for, um, the people who are the followers of God in the Old Testament period. Now, it's important again, it reflects that, you know, it's my, it's my sense that something's wrong. And so I need to rec, it needs to be rectified. It's something wrong in me or something wrong in the nation. So people would fast, um, as a, as a way of expressing their sorrow over a situation. Maybe the nation was facing, uh, a great enemy or the nation had become sinful. And, and so fasting as a sign of grief and mourning and dependence and longing and hope and need, um, and all of that is valid. Um, but by the first century, you know, had kind of like, like many things in faire religion, it had become kind of more about keeping outward checklists. Right?
:Speaker 0 00:07:37 And so in this passage, the, the Pharisees who are the religious leaders at the time, the people who studied the loss group and wanted to follow all of its commands and rules, because they, they believed that that's how they got right with God, and they were blessed by God and they were closer to God. Well, they found their pride in doing this. And so they've narrowed in this conversation. It seems like the topic, like you said is, is fasting, but we could probably spread that out to all kinds of different things if we broadened this for a moment. Yeah. For, for people listening to this talking about religious police or the religion, police in our own lives, there's like you opened up with, there are so many different religions out there that have their own practices and customs, and there are those certain people who take pride in trying to follow those things.
:Speaker 1 00:09:35 Yeah. Or, or you maybe a church that you attended at some point in the past, um, ha was, was structured like that where certain things were expected about how you dressed or, or what you did or didn't do. And there's a long list of dos and don'ts and, um, and, and you know what the, the side effect of that is that everybody's kind of measuring themselves against everybody else. And, and the people who can pull it off or who can look like they pull it off, you know, their stature rises and then they become judgmental of people who, who don't look like they can pull it off or who actually don't. And so, really the outward, the outward appearances or the outward practices might look really the same because whether it's empty religion of some kind, or whether it's true faith in Jesus, you're probably gonna fast. You're probably gonna attend worship. You're probably gonna, you know, serve and give and stuff like that. But, but, um, in, in this toxic religion mindset, the, the religion police are using those kind of lists to, to define who's in and who's out or who's better, who's worse or, or really to prop themselves up in their own pride.
:Speaker 1 00:11:54 Out, no, understands it all. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:13:41 Because Yeah. Because usually there's some pretty good food at weddings. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 1 00:15:22 Elated. Because one, you know, one day like he pointed, he's gonna be gone. And this is a foreshadowing of his crucifixion, it seems like mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:16:47 And that's, that's what Jesus is always getting to do, getting to is the heart of the matter. Yeah. Um, you know, in his famous sermon on the mound, he handles a lot of that. Um, and really it reveals the heart of the religion, police, the Pharisees. Yeah. Yeah. A great point. Even even people around us today that hold to outward rules and conformity, but don't have that joy of, of resting in and, and celebrating in the fact that, you know, even though we mess up and we don't follow all the things on the list, that, that Jesus Christ, the bride groom came and he, he died for us to set us free from the burden. Yeah. The burden of having, having to measure up it shows and, and, and in, in this context specifically, I think that the Pharisees, um, are jealous because they want to be followed. They want to be the ones that people are, are looking to for wisdom and Yep. And following after as teachers Yeah. And rabbis. And so they're a little bit jealous. And it reminds me of imagine, you know, being that guy at a wedding who's in love with the bride to be, but yet he's, but she's, she's getting married to some other guy's,
:Speaker 0 00:18:14 Yeah. And it's, and the Pharisees like that guy in the crowd when, when the, when the preacher says, does anybody have anything against this wedding? Say it now or forever hold your peace. Yeah. You know, and Yeah.
:Speaker 0 00:18:35 Yeah. Imagine saying, no, he's not the right one for her. I am
Speaker 0 00:19:45 Yeah. And that's a really good point that you bring up that Jesus said that because he says, when you fast. Yeah. And so, you know, as we continue to talk about this, Jesus is saying, fasting isn't, isn't over. Right. He hasn't come to like completely get rid of all of the history and all of the customs of, of Judaism altogether. He's really fulfilling it. And, and there's a moment of time here where Jesus is on earth. That's really, I mean, the clear explanation of this text is that mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:21:23 Yeah. Let's explore that just a little bit. I, I think we've talked about spiritual disciplines recently, but, but again, here, fasting is one of those spiritual disciplines, um, can, that can be done in a religious way or it can be done in a, in a heartfelt way to mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:23:05 Yeah. And then even if we think about like re daily devotions, you know, reading, reading the Bible, I, I know me, um, in particular myself, I, there were times where I've had seasons of why did I read the Bible? You know, sometimes it is, I just know that I, I know that it's good for me. Yeah. Even if I don't want to, I make myself do it. That's why it's a, a discipline. Uh, early on though, there, there were motivations. Maybe it wasn't like, you know, to get blessing from God, but sometimes it was, I wanna see how much I can knowledge I can gain so that I can impress people with my knowledge. Right. Um, there were seasons of that in my life and there were seasons of, well I need to read this so that I can share it with other people. Right.
:Speaker 1 00:25:05 Yeah. It's really good point.
:Speaker 1 00:25:50 That's right. We're looking forward to that day mm-hmm.
Speaker 1 00:27:16 This is a little bit of a stretch cuz we don't really practice, uh, either of these things necessarily in our culture. We, we understand like, okay, so in that culture, their clothes were primarily probably made of wool because it was a sh a sheep herding culture. And so I don't know if you've ever had a wool sweater and you threw it in the, in the wash and hot and it's shrunk. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:28:55 Yeah. Thi is this maybe meant to be a, a dig at the Pharisees, you know, maybe saying old dogs can't learn new tricks,
:Speaker 0 00:29:08 So, so what, what's, what's the heart at at what he's getting at be So, so is he saying you guys are following the Old Testament but the the, the New Testament is here. I mean I think a lot of people would, might make that conclusion right? That there's the Old Testament in the Bible and then there's the New Testament. Right.
:Speaker 1 00:30:19 So exactly what is the, the old and new incompatibility. And it seems to me that it's more pointing to the idea of that we've been touching on before about how those things are practiced, about the motive, the purpose, the approach, um, the, the mindset in which those things are practiced. There's a whole new way of approaching certain religious activities that are legitimate in and of themselves, but they've been abused or they've been misunderstood. So let's approach them in a whole different way. And the old approach and the new approach that Jesus, that Jesus is bringing are totally incompatible.
:Speaker 1 00:31:49 We don't, we don't live in a theocracy mm-hmm.
Speaker 1 00:32:31 Mm-hmm.
:Speaker 1 00:33:22 And we, so there's, and we should serve our neighbor and mm-hmm.
Speaker 1 00:34:32 Yeah. It's easy to do,
:Speaker 1 00:34:53 Teach you. Yeah. He's trying to say. And so I, I wanna apply that just as we kinda wrap up here a little bit to two audiences. So yeah, we've applied it to the religious police, to the people who are trying to compare themselves to others. I wanna apply it to, first of all, to people who are coming out of a religious system of some kind. Maybe they're raised in it or whatever, where there's a lot of these kind of external ex uh, uh, expectations. Cuz I wanna say to that person, Hey, don't give up on, um, some of the religious practices they have, meaning they just have a different meaning than what you've been used to. And so sometimes a person coming out of a legalistic religious background will feel like, oh, now I could do whatever I want. Mm-hmm.
Speaker 0 00:36:49 Yeah. Because ultimately our gratitude and the things that we do for God, um, out of love should, should come from understanding the gospel, understanding who Jesus is, understanding that he is the one who came and laid down his life for us. The church we're called his bride. He is the groom. And, and one day he will come back to get us. I I think it's beautiful that it says that, you know, he was gonna be taken away, um, and then they will fast again. Well, there is a time for all of us believers that we actually do long for the day that we get to be with him again. You know, the Bible says that when, when Jesus left and, and, and John and the book of John, he says, I, I go, but I have to go. And when I go, I'm gonna prepare a place for you.
:Speaker 0 00:38:46 Yeah. Where, where we have on the, the wedding garment, uh, and there won't be any holes in it and we won't need to be. So anything, so anything new, there will be wine there that represents joy. There will be feasting because we are celebrating with him. And I think that's what the Pharisees are missing and have missed. And, uh, maybe you're listening to that and you've missed this all along, been a part of religion, but haven't had the relationship. Uh, we implore you today to start a relationship with God by, by trusting in Jesus. And, and if you've messed up and haven't measured up, that's okay. Jesus has come to set you free and save you and, and take your place so that you could have a relationship with God. So that's our third lesson in, in Mark chapter two, as we see Jesus challenging the religious leaders of his day. Uh, don't miss our final session in, in chapter two and it'll bleed into chapter three a little bit as he has one more interaction, uh, in this section. Uh, God bless you guys, and we'll see you next time.